This was included in my Fall Reading list and I just finished it over the weekend. The premise is that Mina Holmes, niece of Sherlock, and Evaline Stoker, sister of Bram, have been asked by Irene Adler to investigate the mysterious deaths of several young socialites. There is time travel, Egyptian mythology, steampunk, and literary allusions aplenty.
The Clockwork Scarab was a fast-paced, plot driven read. It was perfect for destressing from exams and just escaping for a couple hours into this fun world. Although the plots are not very similar, I kept finding myself comparing this to The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. Both are steampunk and feature characters from Sherlock Holmes, though that is where the comparison stops. In many ways, this is what I wanted The League to be. The heroines are smart and witty, they get themselves into trouble and work together to get out, and the mystery at the heart of the story is intriguing.
This isn’t to say that I have nothing but praise for this book. While I enjoyed the steampunk world, it didn’t really have an effect on the plot. The book would have been exactly the same without the steampunk elements. There were also some subplots that seemed shoehorned. The time travel and Dylan character made little sense – I actually kept forgetting that he existed. There’s a chance that his character was just an introduction to a plotline that will become more important in the rest of the series, but in this novel I just didn’t get it. There’s also some angst for Mina about her mom which just never quite fit. It also drove me crazy that Mina and Evaline were so antagonistic – they’re both smart and kickass ladies and there’s really no reason for each to assume the other is a jerk (shine theory, people).
Despite my qualms, I really enjoyed this and look forward to picking up the sequel The Spiritglass Charade, which just came out. SInce the first book ended on a bit of a cliffhanger, I’m looking forward to continuing the series!