This book was a total judge-the-book-by-its-cover impulse buy. I kept seeing it in the bookstore and finally just bought it without even reading the back. I figured with the amazing glow in the dark cover and the title, how could I dislike it?
Turns out, I made the right call. This book was delightful. It was whimsical without being twee and techie without giving me hives. Clay is unemployed, living in San Francisco, and takes a job at the eponymous bookstore, working the night shift. He notices that elderly patrons come in and request strange, old books. The weird part is that they all have discount cards that let them take the books for free. Clay, his Googler girlfriend Kat, and his friend Neel start to investigate and uncover all sorts of centuries-old shenanigans.
My favorite part of this story was the characters. They are all interesting and quirky. I think one of the best things Robin Sloan did was create these characters who are quirky but never adorkable or twee. I enjoy New Girl as much as the next gal, but sometimes you just don’t want that adorable nonsense. They are all resourceful and smart. In many ways the group reminded me of Harry Potter – smart kids piecing together the mystery while a benevolent old man watches.
Where this book lost me was some of the plot elements. It was engaging, with secret societies and geeky tie-ins (I especially like the connections with a fantasy series) but there were times where it just asked a lot of the reader. There comes a point where suspension of disbelief is no longer possible, and this book hit that point for me.
Despite its plotting faults, I really loved this book. I am a sucker for well-written characters and reasonably decent plots and this book delivered. It was the perfect weekend quick read.